Kenyan MSS chief Godfrey Otunge (left) and new PNH chief Normil Rameau (right) during their Jul. 8, 2024 press conference to announce that they were âevaluating and planningâ their next moves. Photo: HaĂŻti LibertĂ©.
By Kim Ives – Jul 10, 2024
As Conille Reports to His Masters
Just over three weeks after he was sworn in on Jun. 3, Haitiâs de facto Prime Minister Garry Conille â without even the knowledge, much less the approval, of the Transitional Presidential Council (CPT) that appointed him â boarded a plane on Jun. 28 to visit Washington, DC, where he reported to his bosses in meetings with U.S. Secretary of State Anthony Blinken, Assistant Secretary of State for Western Hemisphere Affairs Brian Nichols, Deputy National Security Adviser Jonathan Finer, and paymasters from the World Bank and Interamerican Development Bank (IDB), among others.
He then traveled to New York, where he addressed the UN Security Council on Jul. 3. âThe arrival of the Multinational Security Support [MSS] missionâs first contingent is the dawn of a new era in Haiti,â Conille said in his address in French to the body. âHaiti is currently at a critical point with 12,000 armed individuals holding a population of 12 million hostage.â
âWe will restore our territory house by house, neighborhood by neighborhood,â he continued. âThis isnât just a security operation; it is a renaissance of the national spirit.â
Such hyperbole aside, with the honeymoon hardly begun, it already looks like the MSS may âmonte yon resif,â as the KreyĂČl proverb says: hit a reef.
First, all hell continues to break loose in Kenya itself, where massive demonstrations occupied and partially burned the Parliament in Nairobi on Jun. 25 in response to massive tax hikes and austerity cuts which the government proposed so it can try to pay off its crushing $46 billion external debt, owed largely to the International Monetary Fund (IMF).
At first defiant, President William Ruto, whose resignation many are demanding, has bowed to popular ire, rescinded the tax hikes for now, and promised to overhaul his cabinet, although impatience grows with his sluggishness in doing so.
âThe disbandment of the Cabinet is not an expectation but a demand from the people of Kenya,â Nairobi Senator Edwin Sifuna told The Standard. âHe starts off with a serious deficit of trust from citizens; he must convince us otherwise.â
But other opposition leaders think the problem is deeper than a mere lack of sincerity.
âThe only reason why Ruto has not changed his cabinet is because the power brokers around his office are blackmailing him,â said Kisii Senator Richard Onyonka, alluding to the deep corruption that permeates the Kenyan state.
Indeed, violence and greed are at the heart of Kenyaâs political culture today. âAt least 39 people were killed during clashes with the police in June, according to the Kenya National Commission on Human Rights,â the New York Times reported in a long article Jul. 6 article. âAt least 32 people, including activists, medical workers and social media influencers, have been abducted or arbitrarily detained, according to interviews with human rights monitors and dozens of activists, including five who recounted being seized.â
Meanwhile, money is the carrot for the Kenyan police being deployed to Haiti. In short, they are mercenaries.
In Kenya, General Services Unit (GSU) cops â who comprise much of the MSS â make between $373 to $500 monthly, after they just received a 40% raise starting Jul. 1. (Another MSS component, Kenyaâs Administration Police or AP, make even less, starting at $189 monthly). While deployed, they will receive their normal salaries plus between $1,170 and $1,559 monthly, for the rank-and-file soldiers. In contrast, Kenyan MSS Commander Godfrey Otunge makes $7,797 monthly, in addition to other âhuge perks and allowances.â
This wage gap and other bait-and-switch tactics has angered the grunts, as The Standard recently reported. There is âa standoff reportedly pitting junior officers against their seniors over the vexing subject of allowances,â the news site wrote.
For example, deploying MSS cops were promised a $780 (100,000 Kenyan shillings) âdeparture allowanceâ to give to their families, but just before leaving, the allowance was slashed by 80% to a mere $156. âThis is not what they promised us,â one cop anonymously told The Standard. âWhat can it buy? Does it mean that we are leaving our families empty-handed?â
A Kenyan security analyst, George Musamali, complained that the Kenyan soldiers were not even given life insurance. âIt is unheard of,â he told the outlet. âHow do you send an officer overseas without life insurance? This is a life-and-death kind of mission. Letâs face it, not everyone will come out alive, and we have to be aware of this fact.â
It is certain that such grievances and the turmoil at home will impact the morale and effectiveness of the Kenyan troops in Haiti. But the inevitable massacres, abuse, pollution, and resistance that the MSS deployment will bring â as in all previous foreign interventions into Haiti â will likely stoke the growing protest movement back in Kenya, possibly leading to Rutoâs ouster.
If this were to happen, it would be a huge setback for Washingtonâs plans in Africa. Last Sep. 25, U.S. Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin was in Nairobi to ink a still shrouded security deal with Kenya, making it a key U.S. chess piece in East Africa. The Kenyan police deployment to Haiti and the drafting of Kenya into NATO were only parts of Washingtonâs larger plan to use Kenya as its regional cop to fight âterrorismâ and stop the growing influence of Russia and China across Africa.
There are many other signs of trouble back in Haiti. After months of delay and missed deadlines, the first contingent of Kenyan cops finally arrived in Haiti on Jun. 25. Some reports said that it was 400 troops, while others reported only 200. Originally, 1000 Kenyans were supposed to deploy. They would lead other cops from Antigua and Barbuda, Bangladesh, Barbados, Benin, Chad, Guyana, Grenada, Saint Lucia, Dominica, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, Jamaica, Suriname, and the Bahamas. However, none of these small nations have made a firm troop commitment except for Benin ( 2,000 supposedly, more than Kenya) and Bahamas (150).
âThe full force is set to number over 2,500,â Reuters reports, âbut it remains unclear when these could arrive, while funding has lagged far behind requirements.â The U.S. has pledged $300 million, Kenyan officials say the cost will be some $600 million, while a UN fund for the force has only raised $21 million.
So far, the Kenyan cops have only made a couple of photo-op patrols with their Haitian counterparts around Port-au-Prince but have not engaged in any battles with Haitiâs armed groups.
In an effort to reassure, the Kenyan MSS Chief Godfrey Otunge and new Haitian National Police (PNH) chief Normil Rameau held a Jul. 8 joint press conference, but they offered little more than platitudes.
Otunge promised that his men would accomplish their mission âto support the efforts of the National Police, to reestablish security in Haiti, and build security conditions conducive to holding free and fair elections.â
He said the Kenyans and PNH would operate âjoint security operations,â guard âcritical infrastructure sites and transit locationsâ such as âairports, ports, schools, hospitals, and key intersections,â and that the MSS âwill operate and comply with international law⊠and local laws while executing its mandate,â even though its very deployment violates Article 263-1 of Haitiâs 1987 Constitution, tramples a Kenyan Court stay, and disregards the UN Charterâs prohibition against foreign troops interfering in any nationâs internal affairs.
Rameau was somewhat on the defensive, saying that the â15 days [since his appointment] is not 15 months nor three years,â an apparent reference to his deposed predecessor Frantz ElbĂ© lackluster performance.
He said that âweâre coming with new strategies to replace the old ones, which are obsolete, to track the criminals everywhere they are,â and that âweâre in a period of evaluation and planningâ but âfor strategic reasons, we canât go into details.â
Rameau claimed to âknow how [the armed groups] functionâ and explained that some armed group takeovers of police stations were because âpolice have not been present in 7 of Haitiâs 10 departmentsâ but he was working to âallow all the police to return to their posts.â
Rameau wants âthe population to accompany the police in reinforcing this marriage which already has the nickname of MPP, or marriage of the police with the population⊠So we will have the PNH, MSS, and MPP,â he concluded.
Meanwhile, on Jun. 27, Jimmy âBarbecueâ Cherizier, a leader and principal spokesman of the Viv Ansanm (Live Together) coalition of armed groups which prevented the return of former PM Ariel Henry on Feb. 29 and which the MSS is tasked with crushing, released a viral video in which he explains his resistance to the Kenyan deployment.
âAs people who love this country, weâve arrived in a situation where weâre obliged to put our foot down to liberate this country for a second time,â he tells his troops. Sold-out politicians âhave become the tool of the imperialists and have brought foreign troops into the country to continue stealing our resources and killing [founding father Jean-Jacques] Dessalinesâ children⊠The same way they called Dessalinesâ a gang and bandit leader, they call us gang and bandit leaders. But we are the ones here to liberate this country. Today the entire world is watching us, and we have the responsibility to write history. Never forget that!
âThe battle is not a battle for ourselves. In a war, anyone of us can die because it is a battle. But it is better to die fighting than to die as cowards. Die as good soldiers. And just as our ancestors said, anybody who dares step into or attack the quarter where we live, weâll destroy this neighborhood, reducing it to ashes, and weâll continue to fight them even amidst the ashes.
âWe donât care if youâre white or black. If youâre not Haitian, and youâre on our soil, we consider you to be an invader. An invader is never a helper. Remember they already did this to us. They came with MINUSTAH and gave us cholera, and raped young boys and young girls. Today, we are facing history. Remember that what is in your hands are arms to liberate this countryâŠ
âWeâll stand up and fight until our last drop of blood and to liberate this country.
âWe will respect everybody, but we wonât be scared of anybody. We are always open to speak to everybody. But we will never lower our head before anybody. If you are someone who wants to talk to us, weâll talk to you. But if you want to fight with us, weâll fight youâŠ
âAnd in this neighborhood where we live as Haitians, as people they have marginalized, who donât have water to drink or houses to live in, the state makes no professional schools for us and doesnât create the conditions for us to live like people. Today we have to take up arms to liberate our country.
âRemember that they brought the weapons into our neighborhoods, always with the goal of destabilizing the country. And thatâs why every day, every minute, every second, we should always be on guard and ready for the first attack the adversary makes on us. Weâll respond to the adversary immediately.
âI repeated this already. Any one of us could die here, but we should die fighting. And I promise to every man here, and there are other guys who are in their posts, you guys have to carry the message to the other guys in their postsâŠ
âTell those guys this. Iâm the first guy, when they attack, who will fall in the fighting, and Iâm the last guy who will stop fightingâŠ
âWe will repeat for the entire world, contrary to what some would have people think, when we speak of dialogue, a lot of people say we are afraid and that weâre asking for a pardon, which is why weâre talking about dialogue.
âToday I think that people who have military training, or at least have a sense of police security, you know that even when you are fighting, you have to always leave a door open for negotiating.
âThe response we give is clear. We are patriots and nationalists that love this country. Everything that is good for the country, we are ready to enter into dealings which will be good for the country. They are not little personal dealings, dealings where we get money or nice houses. What is important for us today is the majority, the collective. As Thomas Sankara said: âRather than drink champagne with a small group of people, I would rather drink water with everybodyââŠ
âToday, those of us with arms in Viv Ansanm, we are fighting to get water for everybody. I know that a number of groups in Viv Ansanm have done bad things, which society decries. But today, as Dessalinesâ children,⊠we canât let any foreign troops come and assassinate people in the nation.
âPutting our lives on the line, whether our blood flows, weâll continue to fight until our last drop of blood to defend the countryâs sovereignty and integrity.â
On Jul. 5, dressed in a natty red suit, Cherizier made another more formal declaration of the dialogue gauntlet he was throwing down before Conille.
âWe want dialogue, because we want peace,â he said. âThose who donât want dialogue always rely on war⊠and want war⊠Since 1806 [when Dessalines was assassinated] until 2024, itâs been 218 years since the weakest have suffered under the war that the economic, political, social mafias, like the Church mafia, the Media mafia, the human rights mafia⊠have wagedâŠ. The political and economic mafias which promise democracy in the place of dictatorship have not stopped putting strategies in place to sow war among HaitiansâŠ
âThe suffering we have endured has opened the eyes of us former slaves around the country, and we have decided over several years to follow the example of the Cacos and the Piquets, to revolt and take up arms around the country, above all here in the West Department [Port-au-Prince]âŠ.
âToday, letâs focus rather on the true solution which is national dialogue, where every Haitian without discrimination has the right to speak, and thatâs what the mafias donât want⊠We want dialogue because we want to fight against war⊠because we want peaceâŠ
âWhy doesnât PM Garry Conille take the opportunity to have a national dialogue to stop war and create peace across the country?⊠As we wait for Dr. PM Garry Conille to see and understand clearly that national dialogue is the only way the mafias arenât going to control him and lead him down the same road as previous authorities like former Prime Minister Ariel Henry, we have decided to announce publicly that the strategy to silence the guns, put down the guns, and facilitate national dialogue, destroy the mafiasâ war, and encourage peace is already written in black on white in our agenda⊠We want dialogue because we want to stop war and have peace.â
