Nancy Pelosi and a group of US democratic party congress people kneel during a George Floyd memorial in 2020 in a very controversial photo op that did not go well. Photo: AFP via Getty Images.
By Yoselina Guevara López – Jul 26, 2022
The future of United States–China relations may be decided this week by the possible visit to Taiwan of the speaker of the US House of Representatives, Democrat Nancy Pelosi, as part of a tour also taking her to Japan, Singapore, Indonesia, and Malaysia that will begin in August.
So far, neither Washington nor Taipei have ratified Pelosi’s tour, because if confirmed it would damage the already tense relations between Washington and Beijing. For China, this trip would be a clear provocation, since it would have all the components of a state visit, and could be the first by a high-ranking US official since 1997. However, this visit of Pelosi, who holds the third-highest position in the US state, is not a novelty. Pelosi had already planned this tour for last April, just a few weeks after the Russia–Ukraine conflict started, but she had to cancel it because she tested positive for COVID-19.
One China policy
Beijing has already stressed that if Pelosi’s visit takes place, it will take “firm and forceful measures to safeguard its national sovereignty and territorial integrity,” and has called on Washington to comply with the “one China” principle. This policy has maintained the delicate geopolitical balance, which the United States recognizes but does not support, and which consists of China’s claim to Taiwan, as adopted in 1979.
RELATED CONTENT: Taiwan: Red Lines and Strategic Ambiguity
Likewise, the strong Chinese opposition to the visit of the US official could translate into a military response, with air blockades and the imposition of a no-fly zone over the Taiwan Strait to prevent Pelosi from landing on the island, as well as powerful cyber-attacks.
On the other hand, Beijing may be perceiving this tour to Taiwan as a gradual weakening of Washington’s respect for the red line symbolized by the “one China” policy; Beijing has made it clear that it is committed to the full and peaceful reunification of the island, and does not accept “outside interference.” However, in Chinese memory the ambiguous position of Washington is recalled, which has become more evident with the two previous administrations: first, Obama, who launched the “Pivot to Asia;” then, Trump, who started a trade and ideological war with Beijing; and finally, Biden, who is prioritizing US foreign policy in the region to curb Chinese assertiveness. Not to mention that during Donald Trump’s administration, two of his former secretaries, Mike Pompeo and Mark Esper, openly called for the recognition of Taiwan.
For Chinese President Xi Jinping, these are complex times. He must attend to different fronts, divided between sustaining Beijing’s position in the Russia–Ukraine conflict, controlling the protests against the zero-COVID policy, the repercussions of this approach on productivity, and the delicate and no less complex preparations for the 20th Communist Party Congress in November, from which he logically wants to obtain an unprecedented third term in office. Evidently, if Pelosi’s trip is canceled, Beijing could claim a geopolitical success that would rightly be presented as a victory at the Congress, showing Washington to be weak in the eyes of the main Asian capitals, on which the Biden administration is lately focusing its diplomatic attention.
Position of the White House and US Security Forces
The White House has signaled to the press its opposition to Pelosi’s visit to Taiwan, by reporting that the government in Beijing has sent them threatening messages to dissuade the trip. By toughening the discourse, the Chinese government intends, at the very least, to put a limit to the level of officialdom in relations between Washington and Taipei. According to Asian analysts, this visit is interpreted by China as a strategic provocation, and as we pointed out earlier, what is at risk is a military response from Beijing that would not rule out dire consequences for Washington.
Internally in the United States, the debate is divided between those who think that China is weakening and that the time has come to place it in strong difficulties, starting with the Taiwan issue. This is a position that we can call Trumpian, clearly of the Republicans and logically of a part of Congress. But on the other hand, there are the Democrats who believe that it is increasingly likely that a crisis with Beijing could catch the US Armed Forces off guard, so it would be wiser to deactivate provocative mechanisms such as Pelosi’s trip, but without renouncing economic and military containment initiatives; evidently President Joe Biden’s entourage is in favor of the latter position. There is no doubt that this issue will most likely be the focus of the telephone conversation between the US President and his Chinese counterpart, scheduled for the end of this week, provided that the bilateral dialogue is not canceled.
It should be noted that Washington does not seem to be willing to risk an escalation with Beijing. In fact, the US National Security Advisor, Jake Sullivan, and other senior officials of the National Security Council have made public their opposition to Pelosi’s trip because of the risk of an escalation of tensions in the Taiwan Strait. In this sense there is a common ground in the refusal of the trip between the US Security Forces and the White House, let us not forget that Biden alone has no power to prevent the trip. But having two major centers of power against him, including the one that would materially allow the trip, even an autonomous and powerful institution like Congress will have to give in. Let’s hope so.
YG/OT/JRE/SL
Yoselina Guevara
Venezuelan professor. Correspondent for Correo del Alba Magazine in Europe. Her articles have been published in Spanish, Italian and English by different news outlets in Europe (Rebelión, Ideología Socialista, Libya 360, etc) as well as in Latin America (Cubadebate, Redh-Cuba, Redh-Argentina, Portal Alba, Transformar Argentina, Resumen latinoamericano in English, Orinoco Tribune, Quinto Poder Argentina, etc).
