By Sedki Ashour – Mar 20, 2025
I was surprised after reading the American researcher Heather Cox Richardson’s book How the South Won the Civil War.
I am familiar with how Noam Chomsky employs the hypothesis of the “long-term victor” to describe Vietnam’s recent history. Although the Vietnamese expelled the Americans from their country, the United States has emerged as the “long-term victor” of the war. This is particularly evident in Vietnam’s contemporary pivot towards the US and against China.
Richardson’s book applies the “long-term victor” hypothesis to US history in a manner that mirrors our methodology for understanding Lebanese-Palestinian history specifically and Levantine history more broadly. This approach recognizes that while the Lebanese right wing was militarily defeated, it ultimately prevailed in the battle of consciousness, not just within Lebanon but throughout most of the Levant.
Richardson contends that although the Southern Confederacy suffered military defeat, its racist ideology triumphed in the US over the subsequent two centuries. Before the Civil War, Southern landowners weaponized “white identity” to convince white laborers that they shared an identity trench against the Black “other,” enabling wealthy whites to exploit poor whites without accountability or developing class consciousness. Even after the conclusion of the United States Civil War and subsequent Black emancipation, the US capitalist class continued to manipulate racial and identity divisions to maintain control over the lower classes.
A similar distortion of consciousness emerged following the rise of fascism in 1930s Europe, when the alliance between capital and the militarized state fabricated a comparable ideological construct to counter communism.
While German socialists championed the concept of “Kameradschaft” (society of comrades), the German Nazis promoted “Volksgemeinschaft” (racial community) as a competing framework designed to undermine European working-class solidarity. This strategy placed impoverished and wealthy Germans in a shared identity trench positioned against all others.
This white supremacist ideology functions remarkably similarly to Sunni supremacist ideology in the Levant. The relationship between wealthy white slave owners and cotton plantation magnates with poor whites parallels the dynamic between Sunni oil and gas elites in the Gulf states and impoverished Sunnis throughout the Levant. This relationship serves to replace class conflict with sectarian division, effectively deceiving poor Sunnis into believing that they share common cause with wealthy Sunnis against an external sectarian enemy.
Herein lies the crisis of political Sunnism. When presented with the concept of Arab unity based on Sunnis being part of the Arab majority in our region, they respond that “Arabism is a heresy and a pre-Islamic concept. How dare you include me in a majority that encompasses Christian Arabs, Druze Arabs, and Shiite Arabs?” These proponents seek to construct a “majority” that is narrower and more exclusionary to address the question of democratic majority representation in our countries. This emerges from their fundamentally flawed definition of “majority,” as they insist on religious and sectarian parameters rather than recognizing its true nature as the broad working-class populace confronting the alliance between capital and the security apparatus.
On the opposing side stands an equally dangerous and authoritarian form of racism: the concept of an “alliance of minorities.” Following the massacres on the Syrian coast, this discourse has gained traction even among “pro-resistance leftists” who have abandoned strategic thinking and level-headedness, finding themselves aligned with “Israeli” discourse.
Some comrades attempt to persuade me that the “alliance of minorities” in the Levant represents a progressive ideology, matching the Soviet Union’s “Council of Nationalities.” This rhetoric is “not even worth a franc” as Syrians would say colloquially. In practical terms, the “alliance of minorities” in Palestine manifests as being detained at checkpoints by Bedouin, Druze, or Ethiopian soldiers, or by “feminist” female soldiers of the IOF—all serving the same oppressive system.
Translation: Orinoco Tribune
OT/DZ/SC




