As thousands of acres of Brazil’s Amazon rainforest burned, the president of Brazil—exemplifying other men who attempt to assert power over women and environment—made a “disrespectful” comment about France’s First Lady
By Julia Conley
An insulting social media post by Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro aimed at French First Lady Brigitte Macron offered a window into the worldview of powerful men whose destructive policies show no regard for vulnerable populations and the planet at-large, Canadian author and activist Naomi Klein observed Monday.
Bolsonaro remarked on Macron’s appearance while she and her husband hosted the G7 summit and as thousands acres of the Amazon rain forest burned as a result of Bolsonaro’s pro-deforestation policies. Climate action groups have pointed to the president’s encouragement of farmers, loggers, and ranchers who want the forest cleared for their own use, as primary reasons for the blazes.
“Disdain for women’s bodies and disdain for the earth are deeply connected. Both remind idiotic baby men like Bolsonaro and Trump that they are part of web of interdependent life and not the lone heroic figures pretend to be.”
RELATED CONTENT: Bolsonaro & Macron Trade Insults as Amazon Burns (+Sexism)
—Naomi Klein, author On Saturday as leaders from the world’s major economic powers gathered, a supporter of the Brazilian president posted a photo of Bolsonaro and his wife Michelle alongside one of the Macrons, commenting that Macron was jealous of the Brazilian president. Bolsonaro responded in Portuguese, “Do not embarrass the guy… man, ha ha,” prompting anger from critics including the French president.
“I have great respect for the Brazilian people and can only hope they soon have a president who is up to the job,” Macron told the press on Monday, adding that Bolsonaro’s comments were “extraordinarily rude” and a “sad” testament.
In her response to the episode, Klein—who has been an outspoken critic of the policies of Bolsonaro and U.S. President Donald Trump—said the dismissive and objectifying behavior toward women on the world stage by both men goes hand in hand with their shared style of governance during a time when the damaging effects of pro-corporate, pro-fossil fuel policies are becoming increasingly clear.
Anti-climate and anti-women’s rights policies betray the need for both Bolsonaro and U.S. President Donald Trump to assert dominance over the the planet and women—which they know they can never truly control, Klein suggested on Twitter.
“Disdain for women’s bodies and disdain for the earth are deeply connected,” Klein tweeted. “Both remind idiotic baby men like Bolsonaro and Trump that they are part of web of interdependent life and not the lone heroic figures pretend to be.”
Just your morning reminder that disdain for women’s bodies and disdain for the earth are deeply connected. Both remind idiotic baby men like Bolsonaro and Trump that they are part of web of interdependent life and not the lone heroic figures pretend to be. Topple it all. https://t.co/Ik0gNfQHAU
— Naomi Klein (@NaomiAKlein) August 26, 2019
RELATED CONTENT: Honor Marielle Franco and Chelsea Manning
Bolsonaro’s comment mirrored Trump’s treatment of the French first lady in 2017. On an official trip to Paris to meet Macron, Trump drew criticism from lawmakers and women’s rights groups when he was caught on video telling the Macrons that Brigitte was “in such good physical shape.”
Bolsonaro has undone years of work to protect the Amazon by insisting agrobusiness interests should have free reign over the forest that some call “the lungs of the Earth.” Meanwhile, Trump has opened up 378 million acres of public lands for oil and gas drilling, refused to take part in global agreements to curb the climate crisis, and imposed punishing tariffs on burgeoning sustainable energy sectors in order to shore up climate-warming fossil fuel industries—which are run by some of his top financial backers.
On social media, Brazilian anthropologist Debora Diniz also connected Bolsonaro’s misogynist comment to a larger “fascist ideology” that the president uses to keep his underlying “anxiety” under wraps.
“As a Brazilian, I’m ashamed for Bolsonaro’s rudeness against President Macron,” Diniz tweeted. “Sexism was the language to ventilate his fascist ideology which is commonly expressed by sexual anxiety against his political ‘opponents.'”
As a Brazilian, I’m ashamed for Bolsonaro’s rudeness against President Macron. His xenophobic and misogynistic values were ventilate to the world when he disrespected Brigitte Macron and French people.
— Debora Diniz (@Debora_D_Diniz) August 26, 2019
President Bolsonaro was disrespectful of President Macron @EmmanuelMacron and Brigitte Macron. Sexism was the language to ventilate his fascist ideology which is commonly expressed by sexual anxiety against his political “opponents”.
— Debora Diniz (@Debora_D_Diniz) August 25, 2019
Featured image: President Donald J. Trump walks with Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro at the White House on March 19, 2019 in Washington, D.C. (Photo: Jabin Botsford/The Washington Post via Getty Images)
Julia Conley
Julia Conley began her journalism career on PBS's weekly news analysis show Bill Moyers Journal, first as a production assistant and eventually producing interview segments for veteran journalist Bill Moyers. She also worked for over two years as a producer on Al Jazeera America's daily news broadcasts, and later on documentary films focusing on issues including the roots of the American opioid crisis and the history of white supremacy in the U.S. She has written for the quarterly women's magazine A Women's Thing, and joined the Common Dreams staff in 2017
