Whither the âLava Jato Leftâ?

Orinoco Tribune – News and opinion pieces about Venezuela and beyond
From Venezuela and made by Venezuelan Chavistas
By Brasil Wire – Feb 13, 2021
Left wing politicians and commentators who endorsed operation Lava Jato are now under fire for unwittingly helping bring about a Bolsonaro presidency, in what is now being called âThe greatest judicial scandal in historyâ.
As Army-decorated former Judge Sergio Moro and the US-backed Lava Jato task force fall from grace in what has been called the biggest judicial scandal in history, the same is happening to the political coalition which blindly endorsed them, one that was never limited to conservative media and neoliberal commentators.
The so called âLava Jato Leftâ is now facing overdue scrutiny.
Although leaked conversations from the Lava Jato task force have added key detail and reduced deniability, the picture they paint was well articulated long before, both in independent media and academic investigation. Yet until recently even the notion of US involvement in Lava Jato, a matter of public record since 2015, was being glibly dismissed, even by some supposedly on the âleftâ, both in Brazil, and in the Anglosphere.
With available evidence of US involvement growing by the week, combined with admission of a military hand in both the 2016 coup against Dilma Rousseff and the 2018 pre-election jailing of Lula da Silva, former congressman Jean Wyllys turned on members of his party, the PSOL, for their support of operation Lava Jato. Luciana Genro, who was the partyâs presidential candidate in 2014 was the primary target.
For a while Operation Lava Jato was beyond reproach, and any criticism of it was shouted down as Workers Party rhetoric, but the biggest leftist parties, and some internal currents of PSOL, actively protested against the coup, and voiced early concerns about the nascent anti-corruption investigation.
Yet Genro, leader of the MES tendency within the party, was vocal in support for Lava Jato, which PSOL and other smaller vanguard left parties saw as a political opportunity. Decapitation of the PT in a phoney anti-corruption campaign was imagined to be raising the curtain on their own historic moment. It never happened, as the backlash of antipetismo spread into a generalised hysteria against the left.
RELATED CONTENT: Bolsonaroâs Brazil Aided Repression of Chileâs 2019 Protests, Documents Show
Wyllys wrote on social media, posting a screen grab of a 2017 tweet from Genro and the MES, supporting Lulaâs prosecution: âWell, itâs not just âLava Jatoâ accomplices in the commercial media who owe public apologies for their mistake, driven by hatred and political resentment against Lula and the PT. I hope that everyone who went without question into the trap of a âfight against corruptionâ will apologize.â.
Opportunism
Fringe Trotskyist party PSTU, which like the PSOL was formed as a splinter from the Workers Party, also embarrassed itself during this period, with its president ZĂŠ Maria endorsing both the campaign for Dilma Rousseffâs impeachment and the weaponised anti-corruption fight. 2018 presidential candidate Vera LĂşcia Salgado insisted that Lula was âreaping what he had sownâ, in a very unusual BBC interview shortly after his arrest. In 2016 PSTU denied the impeachment of Dilma Rousseff constituted a coup and also dismissed allegations of U.S. connivance, and the motivations behind its involvement in Lava Jato â both of which now proven with court documents â as a âconspiracy theoryâ. Those making non-partisan and founded critiques of imperial and geopolitical undercurrents to what was being done in Brazil were dismissed as âgovernistasâ â blind defenders of the Workers Party.
Green-liberal presidential candidate Marina Silva had the U.S. Governmentâs backing as a centre-left second horse in the race at the 2010 and 2014 elections, with a very similar strategy and political expediency to what Yaku PĂŠrez currently provides in Ecuador. Marina also enthusiastically endorsed both Dilma Rousseffâs impeachment and operation Lava Jato. Denying a coup was in motion, she recommended that her centre-left Rede party vote in favour for Rousseffâs impeachment.
In October 2016, after Lava Jato had helped underpin the campaign for the presidentâs removal, Silva called it âpolitical reform in practiceâ, and claimed that Lava Jatoâs work was âone of the greatest contributions ever made to the countryâ.
After having done just well enough to prevent a first round victory for Dilma Rousseff in 2014, and then backing neoliberal AĂŠcio Neves in the runoff, Marina Silva and her supporters imagined a glorious 2018 election run.
RELATED CONTENT: US Election: Whatâs at Stake for Brazil
Marina Silva came in eighth place with 1% of the vote.
These examples look especially foolish today, but they were not isolated. Whether opportunists or well meaning dupes, manipulation of the media to build public demand for prosecutions was a fundamental of operation Lava Jato, and they fell for it. This use of the press was inspired by Italyâs anti-corruption purge of the 1990s, and the propagandist journalism which enabled its repeat in Brazil is now under justified fire. It was only later that Reginald Bartholomew, Ambassador to Italy at the time, confessed to U.S. involvement. In Italy, as in Brazil, many lament a failure of the far-left to capitalise on Operation Mani Pulite, the inspiration for Lava Jato, rather than acknowledge that what followed was the political result of a concerted effort to remove the left from government. Foot soldiers in a PR campaign which provided cover for what was happening during 2014-2018 are having their embarrassing internet history presented back to them.
Much of a mistrust on the left, which hinders efforts to build a broad front against Bolsonarismo, is a result of such support for Lava Jato and/or Dilma Rousseffâs impeachment. This went beyond normal ideological and political critique of the incumbent president and her administration; there is still resentment that sections of the left seemed prepared to watch Brazil burn for an imagined political advantage which never came. Intense campaigning by vanguard left groups from 2013-16 seemed to evaporate, their presence on the streets noticeably lessened, following Rousseffâs fall.
Pra inglês ver⌠(for the English to see)
The international public relations campaign for Lava Jato is a story in itself, but media omission of U.S. involvement in it now looks increasingly conspicuous, both at the âprogressiveâ end of Anglo corporate media, the New York Times and Guardian, and in publications such as Jacobin which defines itself as socialist. The latter took until August 2020, almost two years after Bolsonaro was elected, to publish even mild critique of the Department of Justiceâs role in Operation Lava Jato which brought him to power, and this came only after leaked Telegram messages made such malfeasance undeniable. Jacobin had published repeated attacks on the Workers Party during the coup period, falsely depicting it as neoliberal. As recently as 2017 it had talked about Lava Jato being an opportunity for the left, and downplayed any imperial connotation to U.S. involvement. Popular podcast the Jimmy Dore show ran several glowing segments on Operation Lava Jato that crossed the line into outright propaganda. Lava Jato was called âa work of artâ, with a co-presenter even saying that he wanted a âLava Jato T-Shirtâ. How the Jimmy Dore show came to be running such blatant prop for a weaponised Brazilian anti-corruption investigation is not known. New Yorker magazine published for its left liberal audience this brazenly pro-Lava Jato article at the time of Lulaâs 2017 prosecution, just as behind closed doors the business and banking community were calling for military intervention. Its author, Bloombergâs Alex Cuadros, dismissed critiques of the operation based in fact. Two years earlier in the NYT he denied that a coup had taken place against Rousseff at all, adding that the Workers Party âhas itself to blameâ for Dilmaâs plight. Just weeks following her ouster, he addressed the libertarian CATO institute, about how her illegitimate impeachment, and the now disgraced Operation Lava Jato, were signals of âstrengthening institutionsâ in Brazil.
Throughout the coup, commentators on left and right long demanded that the Workers Party engage in self criticism, whilst it faced off a lawfare campaign backed by both the Military and the United States, intended to wipe it out as an electoral force. Whatever the vanguard left think about the PT, as it celebrates the 41st anniversary of its founding, it remains the biggest and most successful left wing party in Brazil by a long way, and one which no progressive administration could govern without.
Brazilâs democracy, its economy, and the hard-fought rights of its people were wrecked by operation Lava Jato and the forces behind it. Thus sectors of the left, at home and abroad, which were seduced by a revanchist, reactionary crusade, still need to embark on their own period of thorough self reflection.
Featured image: File Photo
Support Groundbreaking Anti-Imperialist Journalism: Stand with Orinoco Tribune!
For 6.5 years, weâve delivered unwavering truth from the Global South frontline â no corporate filters, no hidden agenda.
Last yearâs impact:
â˘Â 150K+ active readers demanding bold perspectives
â˘Â 158 original news/opinion pieces published
â˘Â 16 hard-hitting YouTube videos bypassing media gatekeepers
Fuel our truth-telling: Every contribution strengthens independent media that actually challenges imperialism.
Be the difference:Â Donate now to keep radical journalism alive!